The pen is mightier than the sword

Unless you live under a rock... hmm, in this case even that might not be true... you have heard of the Muhammad cartoons controversy. The cartoons are poor even by political cartoon standards, for your time you are much better off with The Boondocks. While I do have an opinion on the issue (mostly how a few Muslims are once again paining the color of all Muslims), this post isn't about that. Instead, this is about Wikipedia.

Wikipedia has had some trouble of late. Critics have been quick to point out it's flaws and lay claim that it should be shut down. If you have never been to the site, Wikipedia is a free encyclopedia that you can view... and edit. Now one would think it would be easy to spin a wikipedia article into a tale of lies to make the subject into something it's not. It's not easy though. Everyone can edit, everyone can view, therefore everyone can review. Congress was just woken up to this fact as several congressmen got caught editing (deleting) information from their own articles (a big no-no to edit your own article).

So try as they might, the critic's claim that Wikipedia is full of incorrect information is just not true. Sure there will be articles wrongly changed, but they will be discovered and changed back. The reason I mention the Muhammad cartoons is the talk page. Talk pages on Wikipedia are pages "behind" the article that discuss changes to the article. It is on this page you can see first hand the discussion of should Wikipedia display the image causing such a stir (and it does display the image). The talk page serves a very functional purpose for the article, but also adds color of life to an otherwise black and white encyclopedia. Reading the talk page will gives you a sense of the controversy and a surprising amount of information support each view point. This is what makes Wikipedia truly great, it is the implementation of the ideal of freedom of speech.

Posted By Mike On Thursday, February 09, 2006
Filed under politics | No Comments

Submit this story to DotNetKicks   

Leave a comment



Your name:
 

Your email (not shown):
 
Will display your Gravatar image.

Your website (optional):



About Michael

Michael C. Neel, born 1976 in Houston, TX and now live in Knoxvile, TN. Software developer, currently .Net focused. Board member of ETNUG and organizes CodeStock, East Tennessee's annual developers conference. .Net speaker, a Microsoft ASP.NET MVP and ASPInsider. Co-Founder of FuncWorks, LLC and GameMarx.

Proud father of two amazing girls, Rachel and Hannah, and loving husband to Cicelie who inflates and pops his ego as necessary.

 Subscribe to ViNull.com |  Comments

Follow me on Twitter | Contact Me

Related Posts

Tor: I always feel like, somebody's watching me

I have always been interested in how the Internet can be used for or against freedom (as in speech).  The EFF is the best place on the web to know ... Read more

Voting is so important, do it twice or more!

This coming election will see the greatest number of electronic voting machines in history.  Technology changes everything, and voting is no exception.  ... Read more

Pushing the Big Blue Button

It's just started to hit the wire, but the news is IBM has sued Amazon over infringing patents.  I haven't had any luck tracking down the claims IBM ... Read more

The claws of the RIAA are long

By way of Ars today came an article that Visa will no longer allow consumers to use AllofMP3.  If you are not familiar with AllofMP3 they are a Russian ... Read more

Mr Conservative: Barry Goldwater

I just finished watching "Mr. Conservative: Goldwater on Goldwater," a documentary on HBO.  If you don't have HBO, you'll have to wait for a video ... Read more

XNA 3D Primer by Michael C. Neel

XNA 3D Primer by Michael C. Neel
Buy Now: [ Amazon ] [ Wrox ]

GameMarx

CodeStock

ASPInsiders Member

ETNUG Member