Pushing the Big Blue Button

It's just started to hit the wire, but the news is IBM has sued Amazon over infringing patents.  I haven't had any luck tracking down the claims IBM submitted to a court in Texas yesterday, but it appears they cited 5 patents.  These patents are said to involve "Amazon's entire business" and cover ad targeting, storing data, and ordering from an electronic catalog.  The patents were filed in the 1980's though early 1990's.

When I get the text of the lawsuit, and the patents involved, I'll do a detailed breakdown of the case.  Right now however I can only comment on the issues this will present.  The biggest issue bar far is the "Software Patent" - many of the things patented under a software patent are merely computers doing a job that was once done without a computer.  One patent said to be in the lawsuit is IBM's "Placing an order on an electronic catalog" - which is nothing new if you take away the work "electronic."  A patent is supposed to be non-obvious to someone who works in the field of the patent, and I'm willing to bet most software patents do not meet that test.

There is also the issue of the purpose of a patent.  A patent is to allow an inventor the time to recoup his investment in developing a working version of his idea and get it to market.  Now I'm not for patents in general, but lets look at a drug patent.  It can take years to tens of years to get a drug though all the testing required by federal laws so it can be sold to the public, and that cost adds up.  Looking at software, it takes a moment to have the idea and a week to code it (most of the time in software development is spent on issues not related to the core logic of the program, the part under patent).  If we are talking about something that will fit into a website, like Amazon's "One-Click" patent, it can even be deployed within a month.  So there isn't much investment of inventor time even if we excuse the non-obvious requirement.

IBM suing Amazon is also a breakdown of these tow companies stand on patents.  In the past, IBM has applied for patents most for defensive purposes - to use when they were sued over a patent.  Amazon started out along evil lines, but since then Amazon founder Jeff Bezos has helped gain support for patent reform legislation.  Now that IBM has launched a full scale invasion, claiming Amazon owes royalties on every dollar earned, I expect gloves to come off and a counter suit from Amazon because I'm sure Amazon can find a few patents it holds to use against IBM.  And then we play Global Thermonuclear War (IBM would do so well at chess too).

Personally?  I say let the nukes fly.  A full scale war would scare any technology company into supporting patent reform, and maybe, just maybe, dropping the whole idea.

Article appears on KnoxViews

Update: Ars has posted an article citing the exact patents involved.

Posted By Mike On Tuesday, October 24, 2006
Filed under politics ibm amazon | Comments (3)

Submit this story to DotNetKicks   

Tish - Wednesday, October 25, 2006 2:10:05 AM

So glad you posted your article on KnoxViews as well! About time! ;)

Guess what? I just posted with Flock!

Mike - Wednesday, October 25, 2006 1:41:10 PM

I got a comment on KnoxViews from a person who used to work in the patent office as a reviewer - that is pretty damn sweet. It look like KnoxViews needs a Techo-Legal-Political writer and I'm happy to step in =p

Thanks for pointing me to the site!

Lucie - Saturday, May 10, 2008 2:33:50 PM

THis Is A load Ov Shit

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated manually.

Your name:

Your email (not shown):
Will display your Gravatar image.

Your website (optional):

About Michael

Michael C. Neel, born 1976 in Houston, TX and now live in Knoxvile, TN. Software developer, currently .Net focused. Board member of ETNUG and organizes CodeStock, East Tennessee's annual developers conference. .Net speaker, a Microsoft ASP.NET MVP and ASPInsider. Co-Founder of FuncWorks, LLC and GameMarx.

Proud father of two amazing girls, Rachel and Hannah, and loving husband to Cicelie who inflates and pops his ego as necessary.

 Subscribe to ViNull.com |  Comments

Follow me on Twitter | Contact Me

Related Posts

Tor: I always feel like, somebody's watching me

I have always been interested in how the Internet can be used for or against freedom (as in speech).  The EFF is the best place on the web to know ... Read more

Voting is so important, do it twice or more!

This coming election will see the greatest number of electronic voting machines in history.  Technology changes everything, and voting is no exception.  ... Read more

The claws of the RIAA are long

By way of Ars today came an article that Visa will no longer allow consumers to use AllofMP3.  If you are not familiar with AllofMP3 they are a Russian ... Read more

Mr Conservative: Barry Goldwater

I just finished watching "Mr. Conservative: Goldwater on Goldwater," a documentary on HBO.  If you don't have HBO, you'll have to wait for a video ... Read more

Rumsfeld is one bad mother...

Crooks and Liars is hosting a copy of MSNBC anchor Keith Olbermann's commentary on Donald Rumsfeld.  It is in response to Rumsfeld's recent speech, ... Read more

XNA 3D Primer by Michael C. Neel

XNA 3D Primer by Michael C. Neel
Buy Now: [ Amazon ] [ Wrox ]



ASPInsiders Member

ETNUG Member